HOME

How-To

Reviews 

News

Downloads

Forum

Workshops

Shop     

Staff 

 

Photoshop for Enthusiasts:

Adobe Photoshop CS3 - Justified Upgrade?

When Photoshop CS3 was publicly released in its beta version, writers and reviewers around the world rushed to be the first to describe its new features.  They rushed so quickly, in fact, that it was hard to believe that they could, in days, review so rich and deep a program as Photoshop. And that even before the final commercial product was released for sale. 

After decades in high tech, I’ve not yet encountered a perfect beta with fully working program elements.  So how, I questioned, could all these writers possibly make a recommendation without first spending LOTS of time working with the commercial release of this massively deep and rich software?  Still, attendees at my Photoshop classes and workshops were asking for objective recommendations to guide them about upgrading to this newest version and the vast majority of photography enthusiasts need stronger reasons than saving two minutes in workflow to justify a significant upgrade investment. 

So that I could offer them objective feedback based on my personal experience with the newest version of Photoshop, I chose to go “slow and steady” in developing my opinions.  I’m confident that, now, I’m finally ready to give my honest appraisal to all those questioners who’ve waited patiently for my point of view about whether or not it makes sense for them to invest in Adobe’s Photoshop CS3 upgrade, given their dollars available for this versus other gear.

Given that background and perspective, my opinion is decidedly yes!  Although I’ve often been reticent in reviews to give an unqualified “go ahead” because of program imperfections and operational flaws, this is not the case with Photoshop CS3.

Let’s look at the version improvements behind my unqualified “go do it!”   Here, though, are the four Photoshop CS3 compelling features that, to me, do justify the upgrade for enthusiasts. These are the “must haves,” the features that I believe will be the differentiating advancements that can further unleash the power of your “digital darkroom:”

·         Opening a Raw file in Photoshop CS3 triggers the latest iteration of Adobe RAW.  I liked Adobe’s previous Raw file handler, but not enough to change from the ones that Nikon and Canon provided for use with their cameras’ RAW file formats. But this latest Adobe RAW edition is nothing less than awesome. It’s now my Raw file handler of choice; the Nikon and Canon plug-ins have been removed from their folders and safely parked in a dark corner in the inactive archival recesses of my computer. I love its more accurate histograms, not to mention the full color histogram option. It lets me tweak my exposure, white balance and color with full preview at the time when RAW images should be tweaked, before they’re opened as Photoshop PSDs or another “developed” picture file format.

·         Photoshop CS3’s Quick Selection tool is, in most cases, much superior to and far faster than Photoshop’s other selection tools. It reduces the toil of trying to achieve a smooth selection because you can now roughly “paint” over the selection you want and Photoshop CS3 will determine its edges. (This approach is used in many third-party masking plug-ins which can also be used with older Photoshop CS versions. These plug-ins can also usually be more delicately “tuned,” as well. For the record, though, they typically cost as much as the Photoshop CS3 upgrade would.) Still, this tool is a huge advance for those users who don’t have a third-party masking plug-in.  Making good selections has continued to be one of the most difficult tasks for all but the most highly experienced Photoshop user to master.  This new tool will help the beginner and intermediate Photoshopper take a big step forward.

·         If you only have one monitor with which to work – the case with most enthusiasts – Photoshop CS3 allows you to play hide-and-seek with its screen-consuming palettes, tucking them invisibly away until you need and recall them. You can work at your full-screen size without hiding half your picture. That, by itself, buries a major source of frustration and justifies the upgrade for many, many users!  If you think that hiding the palettes at will is a minor thing on today’s wide screens, consider that most digital cameras record a wider image than film cameras did. You can usefully use that extra image room on your screen. Icing on the cake is the ability to reconfigure the toolbar in a single vertical column, consuming even less image-stealing space.

·         Black-and-white photography is back with a vengeance and, if you’re caught in that wave, Photoshop CS3’s new B&W conversion tools are very welcome and much improved. You can modify your image using the digital equivalent of the primary color filters that made B&W film photography such a wonderful medium of expression. You’ve got presets and sliders to control Red, Blue, Green, Cyan, Magenta and Yellow for individual control of filtering and tint. Watch those clouds pop, skin tones mellow and greenery brighten.  How ‘bout an infrared look? Sliders sound too complicated? You can always hit the Auto option.

Major requirements for Photoshop CS3? A big, fast, memory-stuffed PC is a good place to start. Photoshop CS3 really does seem to load and run faster than CS2 does on my Microsoft Windows XP-based desktop (recently upgraded from 1.5GB to 2GB of DDR memory.  That extra half GB of DDR seems to help everything run noticeably faster with far fewer hard disk accesses. It should. Photoshop is a memory-intensive graphics program. There is nothing better you can do to improve a memory-intensive graphics program’s performance than adding more memory to your PC.  (Don’t blame Photoshop for the software bloat that forces that RAM upgrade. The guilty culprit is Microsoft with its myriad Windows XP patches that now practically cripple computers with smaller amounts of installed memory. One GB doesn’t cut it anymore for the digital darkroom. It barely makes it for the OS. Today’s XP operating system consumes so much available memory that too little is left for a smooth, fast-running memory intensive application like Photoshop without its falling back on a less desirable alternative: constant read-writes to your hard drive which works something like dragging Photoshop or any other graphics app through digital molasses. Photoshop thrives on memory the same way that a vegetable garden thrives on sunlight and water. Give it more and it is more productive. (If you’re running Vista , don’t even begin to think of any amount of memory less than 2GB as your starting point.)  

What’s that? You’re using a new Intel-based Mac? Than a Photoshop upgrade is even more of a “no-brainer” buy for you.  CS3 is the first version to run natively on these Macs.

Adobe